We’ve all been there—scrolling late at night trying to find return gifts that are fun, affordable, and won’t end up forgotten at the bottom of a toy bin. Don’t worry, I’ve got you covered.
Choosing the perfect birthday favors for little girls isn’t just about the gift itself; it’s about making them feel loved and appreciated. From playful arts and crafts to delightful treats, the possibilities are endless.
Let’s dive into some creative return gift ideas that are sure to impress both the little ones and their parents. Whether you’re on a tight budget or looking to splurge a little, there’s something here for every birthday celebration!
Contents
- 1. Mini Craft Kits
- 2. Personalized Storybooks
- 3. DIY Friendship Bracelets
- 4. Puzzle Sets
- 5. Play-Doh Sets
- 6. Cute Hair Accessories
- 7. Magical Seed Kits (You Won’t Believe #7!)
- 8. Fun Water Bottles
- 9. Art Supplies Pack
- 10. Spinning Tops
- 11. Animal Figurines
- 12. Bubble Wands
- 13. Fun Board Games
- 14. Colorful Building Blocks
- 15. Custom Coloring Bags
1. Mini Craft Kits

Every toddler loves to get their hands sticky with glue and paint. Mini craft kits are perfect return gifts as they not only entertain but also foster creativity. With a simple kit containing stickers, colored paper, and crayons, kids can unleash their imagination and take home a piece of the party.
These kits often come in cute packaging, making them delightful to unwrap. Plus, they can be customized based on the interests of the birthday girl; think princess themes, animals, or even seasonal designs. Kids can share their creations back home, giving them a sense of accomplishment.
– Consider including an instruction sheet with fun ideas for using the supplies.
– Look for eco-friendly materials to align with sustainable values.
– Make it a bonding activity by encouraging parents to join in on the fun.
Overall, mini craft kits are an absolute hit among toddlers!
Product Recommendations:
2. Personalized Storybooks

Imagine a storybook where your child’s name is the star! Personalized storybooks are an enchanting way for toddlers to engage in reading. These books typically feature beautiful illustrations and tales that revolve around the child’s adventures, making reading time extra special.
Parents can gift a storybook that includes their child’s name as well as those of their friends, creating a shared literary experience. These books encourage a love for reading, spark imagination, and make bedtime routines a joy.
Consider options where the story can be tailored to various themes—like princesses, superheroes, or magical lands.
– Look for publishers who offer customizable options ensuring quality and creativity.
– Gift wrapping can include a personalized note from the birthday girl, making it even more special.
With personalized storybooks, every child becomes the hero of their own adventure!
Product Recommendations:
• Personalized Children’s Books by Wonderbly
• My Very Own Name: A Personalized Storybook by I See Me!
• The Little Boy or Girl Who Lost Their Name by Lost My Name
3. DIY Friendship Bracelets

Nothing says friendship like handmade jewelry! DIY friendship bracelet kits are wonderful return gifts that allow toddlers to create something special for their friends. These kits typically include colorful threads, beads, and instructions to help them craft their own unique designs.
Not only do these bracelets make adorable keepsakes, but they also encourage sharing and bonding among little ones. Having a creative session at the party to make these bracelets can double as a fun activity!
– Choose kits that promote fine motor skills, boosting dexterity while having fun.
– Consider themed colors that match the birthday party for a personalized touch.
– Include a friendship note or a small pouch for them to carry their new creations home.
DIY friendship bracelets are a beautiful way to celebrate camaraderie!
4. Puzzle Sets

Puzzles are not just entertaining; they help develop problem-solving skills and hand-eye coordination! Gifting a simple yet fun puzzle set as a return gift can offer hours of engagement for toddlers.
Choose puzzles with cheerful themes such as animals, vehicles, or fairy tales, ensuring they are age-appropriate. Puzzles are perfect for playdates, allowing children to work together to complete them.
Consider including a fun carrying case or bag, making it easy for kids to take their puzzles wherever they go.
Insights:
– Look for eco-friendly puzzles made of sustainable materials.
– Personalize the experience by adding a small thank-you note from the birthday girl.
– Host a mini puzzle challenge at the party for added fun.
Puzzles are timeless gifts that keep on giving, making them a brilliant choice!
Product Recommendations:
• Melissa & Doug Animal Parade Jigsaw Puzzle
• Ravensburger Fairy Tale Puzzles
5. Play-Doh Sets

Every child loves the squishy, moldable goodness of Play-Doh! This classic gift is perfect for fostering creativity as kids can sculpt, design, and create whatever their imagination conjures.
Play-Doh sets often come with fun molds, tools, and vibrant colors that entice toddlers to explore the world of creative play. These kits not only provide sensory delight but also encourage imaginative play and fine motor skills.
for gifting:
– Include cookie-cutters or themed molds that can inspire unique creations.
– Consider eco-friendly options or natural dough sets for a healthier choice.
– A colorful storage container can add a layer of organization for post-party playtime.
Play-Doh sets are a delightful return gift that promises giggles and creativity long after the party ends!
Product Recommendations:
• Play-Doh Classic 10-Pack of Colors
• Play-Doh Kitchen Creations Magical Oven
• Play-Doh Animal Crew 3-Pack of Molds
6. Cute Hair Accessories

For little girls, nothing is as delightful as adding flair to their hairstyles! Hair accessories such as colorful clips, headbands, and scrunchies make practical and charming return gifts. These little treasures can turn any simple hairdo into a fashion statement!
Choose sets that come beautifully packaged, perhaps in a small, reusable pouch or box, making them easy to carry home. Consider different themes like flowers, rainbows, or animals, appealing to the tastes of different toddlers.
– Look for durable but lightweight materials that are gentle on young hair.
– Customize the sets based on the birthday girl’s favorite colors to create a personal touch.
– Host a mini hair-styling session at the party, allowing kids to try on their new accessories.
Cute hair accessories are not only fashionable but also empower young girls to express themselves through their styles!
Product Recommendations:
• Cute Hair Accessories Set for Girls
• Rainbow Hair Clips and Headbands for Toddlers
• Colorful Scrunchies for Kids
7. Magical Seed Kits (You Won’t Believe #7!)

Bringing a touch of nature into the lives of toddlers can be magical! Seed kits allow little ones to plant their own flowers or vegetables, creating a wonderful bond with nature. This return gift not only teaches kids about responsibility but also about how things grow.
Imagine their joy as they watch their tiny seeds sprout and bloom! Most seed kits come with pots, soil, and cute labels, making it a delightful gardening experience for kids.
– Choose easy-to-grow seeds like sunflowers or marigolds that thrive in various conditions.
– Include a small booklet with gardening fun facts and pictures to engage their curiosity.
– Consider hosting a mini potting party at the event where friends can plant their seeds together!
Magical seed kits are unique and purposeful return gifts that inspire little ones to embrace the wonders of nature.
Product Recommendations:
• Gardening Seed Starter Kit for Kids
• Sunflower Seed Kit for Kids with Pots and Soil
• Marigold Seed Growing Kit for Kids
8. Fun Water Bottles

Staying hydrated is vital, and what better way to encourage it than with fun, colorful water bottles? These practical return gifts can be customized with fun characters or themes that resonate with toddlers.
Look for kid-friendly designs that are easy to hold and carry, ensuring fun and practicality. Some bottles come with built-in straws or fun shapes, making drinking water an enjoyable adventure!
Ideas:
– Consider including a personal touch, like a name tag or sticker for each bottle.
– Choose bottles made from BPA-free materials for safety.
– Host a mini water bottle decorating station at the party.
Fun water bottles are both useful and appealing, making them a perfect return gift choice!
Product Recommendations:
• Colorful BPA-Free Water Bottles with Straw
• Personalized Water Bottles for Kids
9. Art Supplies Pack

Encouraging creativity should be high on your list! An art supplies pack filled with crayons, sketch pads, watercolor paints, and stamps makes for an exciting return gift. This gift gives toddlers the tools they need to express their feelings and let their imagination run wild.
Look for packs that come in a handy carrying case, making it easy for kids to transport their new art supplies anywhere they go. To make the gift even more special, include a unique sketch pad with fun prompts, encouraging their creative juices to flow!
– Include different colors, textures, and mediums to keep things exciting.
– Create a small guide with tips on drawing or painting to inspire them.
– Consider collaborating with a local artist to create themed kits that resonate with toddlers.
Art supplies packs are a gateway to endless creativity for children!
Product Recommendations:
• Crayola Inspiration Art Case
• Melissa & Doug Watercolor Paint Set
• ALEX Toys Little Hands Art Studio
10. Spinning Tops

Spinning tops are classic toys that never go out of style! These little wonders bring joy and laughter as children watch them whirl and spin. Gifting beautifully designed wooden or colorful plastic tops can provide endless entertainment.
Toddlers can race their tops or even create competitions to see which spins the longest. Different tops can come in various themes—like space, animals, or flowers—creating a magical experience for kids.
– Look for sets that include multiple tops for sharing and playing together.
– A small guide with fun spinning games can enhance their play experience.
– Consider choosing eco-friendly wooden options for a natural touch.
Spinning tops are a delightful and nostalgic return gift that sparks joy in budding explorers!
Product Recommendations:
• Colorful Plastic Spinning Tops for Kids
• Eco-Friendly Wooden Spinning Tops with Animal Designs
11. Animal Figurines

Kids love to play and learn about animals! Animal figurines make fantastic return gifts. These little toys encourage imaginative play, allowing toddlers to create their own wildlife adventures right at home.
Opt for sets that include a variety of animals, from farmyard friends to jungle creatures, making learning about different species fun. Some sets even come with a mini play mat for enhanced playtime experiences!
Insights:
– Choose eco-friendly materials or ethically sourced figurines for a responsible gift choice.
– Look for options that are safe for toddlers, with no small parts.
– Create a small booklet with fun facts about each animal, so kids can learn while they play.
Animal figurines inspire endless storytelling and creativity in toddlers!
Product Recommendations:
• Animal Planet Wild Animal Figurines
• Schleich Farm World Animal Figurines Set
• Learning Resources Jumbo Farm Animals Set
12. Bubble Wands

Nothing brings joy like bubbles floating through the air! Bubble wands are fun and magical return gifts that kids can enjoy both during the party and at home. They’re perfect for outdoor play, providing endless entertainment as toddlers chase and pop the shimmering bubbles.
Choose wands with different designs or sizes for added excitement, and consider including scented bubble solutions for an extra twist!
– Create a bubble station at the party where kids can experiment with different wands.
– Include a small pouch or bag for transporting their bubble accessories home.
– Consider eco-friendly bubble solutions to promote sustainability.
Bubble wands are a fantastic way to bring joy and laughter into a toddler’s day!
Product Recommendations:
• Bubbles Kids Bubble Wand Set
• Premium Scented Bubble Solution
• Eco-Friendly Bubble Wands for Kids
13. Fun Board Games

Introduce toddlers to the world of friendly competition with simple board games. These games are not only entertaining but also promote social interaction and teamwork. Look for age-appropriate options that are easy to understand, ensuring everyone can join in on the fun.
Games with bright colors and engaging characters are sure to attract the little ones’ attention. Include a lightweight carry bag so they can take their game home!
Insights:
– Choose games that encourage cooperation over competition to foster friendship.
– Host a mini game tournament during the party to showcase the fun!
– Consider games with educational elements to sneak in some learning while playing.
Fun board games are a great way to spark joy and laughter among toddlers!
Product Recommendations:
14. Colorful Building Blocks

Building blocks are timeless toys that stimulate creativity and problem-solving skills. These colorful sets allow kids to construct anything they can imagine, from houses to castles! Look for sets that are made of lightweight, durable materials for ease of play and safety.
Many sets also come in various colors and shapes, encouraging toddlers to experiment with design and construction. They can even collaborate with friends to create larger projects!
– Personalize the gift by adding a creative building guide with fun challenges.
– Consider eco-friendly options to promote environmental consciousness.
– Organize a mini building competition during the party for extra fun.
Colorful building blocks inspire creativity and open-ended play!
Product Recommendations:
• Melissa & Doug Wooden Building Blocks Set
• LEGO DUPLO Classic Brick Box
• Tegu Magnetic Wooden Blocks Set.
15. Custom Coloring Bags

Transform a simple gift into something extraordinary with custom coloring bags! These bags can feature pre-printed designs that toddlers can color themselves, making each one a unique masterpiece. Filled with non-toxic coloring supplies like crayons or markers, these kits provide endless hours of fun.
Not only do they encourage artistic expression, but they also promote patience and focus. Choose themes that resonate well with toddlers, such as animals, fairy tales, or their favorite movie characters.
– Look for environmentally friendly materials for both the bags and the coloring supplies.
– Create a little competition where kids can showcase their colored bags for extra engagement!
– Include a small booklet with coloring ideas or prompts for inspiration.
Custom coloring bags are creative, personal, and sure to be cherished by little ones!
Product Recommendations:
• Custom Coloring Bags for Kids
• Non-Toxic Crayon Set for Toddlers
• Eco-Friendly Coloring Markers for Children
Conclusion

Selecting the perfect return gifts for a toddler’s birthday is all about celebrating creativity and shared experiences. The ideas presented here are not only fun but also add a personal touch that kids will cherish long after the party has ended.
Whether you choose craft kits, personalized storybooks, or magical seed kits, each gift carries the potential for joy and learning. Let your little one and her friends create lasting memories with these thoughtful and creative return gifts!

Leave a comment